A factory may process FSC-certified timber alongside conventional timber every day. Both materials can pass through the same warehouse, use similar equipment, and become part of products that look almost identical when they leave the production line.
The challenge begins when the company needs to establish which materials were used in a particular product and what claims can legitimately be made about it.
A supplier invoice may identify the incoming material, but that alone does not establish how the material was handled afterward. Warehouse staff may move stock between locations, production teams may combine batches, and leftover materials may return to inventory. At each stage, the company needs a reliable way to distinguish FSC-certified inputs from non-FSC materials and maintain the records needed to support its product claims.
Under FSC Chain of Custody (CoC), this is not simply a matter of keeping two types of materials in separate piles. It requires a control system that connects material identification, inventory management, production activities, and sales documentation.
FSC-certified and non-FSC materials can be handled within the same production facility, provided the applicable FSC requirements are met and the company uses an appropriate control system.
The key distinction is that sharing a production system does not mean treating all materials as equivalent.
FSC-certified inputs have a defined status supported by supplier documentation and applicable FSC claims. Non-FSC inputs do not automatically acquire that status because they enter the same facility, pass through the same machinery, or become part of the same product range.
The company must be able to determine which materials are eligible for use in FSC product groups and how their status is maintained throughout the production process.
Depending on the operation, this may involve physical segregation, clear identification, controlled handling procedures, or other measures permitted under the applicable FSC requirements. The appropriate approach depends on the materials, production flow, and control system used by the company.
The objective is straightforward: material status must remain clear, and the FSC claims made on finished products must be supported by the applicable requirements and records.
The most difficult control issues do not always occur during production. They can emerge during routine activities that seem unrelated to certification.
Inventory and production records serve different purposes, but they should not contradict each other.
Stock records help establish what material the company received, its status, where it was stored, and how much remains available. Production records show how material was issued and processed, and how much output was generated.
Consider a simple example.
A company receives an FSC-certified material batch and records 1,000 units in inventory. Production later issues 600 units to a manufacturing order. The company records the remaining 400 units as available stock.
The figures are only meaningful if the production records can establish what happened to the 600 units issued. The resulting output, any relevant conversion factors, and any production losses need to be accounted for according to the company's process and applicable FSC requirements.
If the stock system shows 400 units remaining but the production records do not explain the 600 units issued, the company has a gap in its material accounting. If the finished-product records also fail to connect the output to the original input, traceability becomes more difficult to demonstrate.
This does not mean every business needs an expensive or complex software platform. A well-controlled spreadsheet-based system may be suitable for some operations. What matters is whether the records are accurate, consistently maintained, and sufficient to demonstrate the required material flow and claims.
Even when material handling and production records appear complete, the final product claim still needs to be verified.
An FSC claim on an invoice, delivery document, or other applicable sales record must be consistent with the product's eligibility, the company's certificate scope, and the relevant FSC requirements. The claim cannot be based solely on the fact that some FSC-certified material was used somewhere in the facility.
For example, if an order was intended to use FSC-certified inputs but the production team accidentally issued non-FSC material, the company cannot simply retain the intended FSC claim and correct the paperwork later. It must assess the discrepancy, follow its documented procedures, and determine what claims, if any, are permitted for the affected output.
A useful final control is to compare the finished product and its production records against the sales documentation before the claim is issued. This helps identify discrepancies while the order is still traceable and before the claim reaches the customer.
The principle is simple: a product claim must reflect what the company's records and applicable FSC rules can substantiate, not what the company intended to produce.
Managing FSC and non-FSC materials in one production system requires more than a written procedure. Companies should review whether their actual operations still match the controls documented in their FSC CoC system.
This review can include:
These checks are particularly relevant when a company changes its operating model. A control procedure that worked for a limited product range may no longer be sufficient after the business adds new materials, introduces additional production steps, or outsources part of its processing.
The purpose of reviewing the system is not to add unnecessary paperwork. It is to identify where material status could become unclear and ensure that controls remain effective under actual operating conditions.
FSC and non-FSC materials do not necessarily require completely separate production facilities. They do, however, require a control system that prevents their status from being confused and ensures that product claims remain supported.
That control begins when material is received and continues through identification, storage, internal movement, production, inventory reconciliation, and sales documentation. A weakness at any stage can affect the company's ability to demonstrate traceability.
For companies applying FSC CoC 3.0, the practical question is not simply whether FSC and non-FSC materials are present in the same facility. It is whether the company can account for their movement and demonstrate that every FSC claim is permitted and supported by the relevant records.
Foresta Consulting helps companies review their FSC Chain of Custody processes, identify gaps in material control, and strengthen the alignment between documented procedures and actual production practices. Contact Foresta Consulting to discuss your company's FSC CoC certification needs.